A Credible Downgrade?

On Friday Standard & Poor’s lowered the AAA credit rating of the United States. The new credit rating is now AA+ and it marks the first time in history that the U.S. has had its credit rating lowered. It probably doesn’t even need mention that this will serve as political ammunition for opponents to President Obama. It will be beside the point that the Republicans use of the debt ceiling for political advantage is the only reason the United States came precariously close to a first ever default on its financial obligations.

Was this rating warranted in the first place? Why do we still take rating agencies seriously? Why do these agencies have the power that they do over our financial markets and now, as it would appear, over our political system? After all, this is the same Standard & Poor’s that had no problem handing out favorable ratings for the various exotic mortgage backed security instruments that led to the financial meltdown in 2008. But it appears that the rating agencies didn’t suffer any consequences from their incompetence during the financial disaster. That probably should not be surprising because much of Wall Street also suffered very little while the rest of the country struggles to find work and pay the bills.

Recommended reading:

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on RedditPin on PinterestShare on TumblrDigg thisShare on StumbleUponShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone


#AA+#AAA#credit#economy#financial meltdown#rating#rating agency#S&P#Standard & Poor's#united states

  • Krys

    I’ve been wondering the same thing. These are the same agencies who helped get us into this financial mess in the first place. And now we’re going to panic and ruin the economy even more because they claim the US isn’t as credit-worthy as it was a week ago? I don’t claim there isn’t vast room for improvement in how we handle our country’s finances, but I think depending on these rating agencies, who have shown themselves to be undependable, is throwing fuel on the fire. It’s unnecessary and making matters worse.

  • d.k.sutton

    An interesting tidbit from their assessment is the use of the word “brinkmanship”. I realize they were probably applying it to the entire political process. But any honest assessment of what went on the past few weeks would conclude that both parties were playing politics but that it was indeed the Republicans and the tea party that pushed us to near default. Democrats would have accepted a clean bill raising the debt ceiling just as it’s always been done. The debt ceiling is not the place to have a fight over the budget.